Code shipped, gym session logged, nighttime stroller loop finished. Three tiny wins that—done often enough—stop feeling like chores and start sounding like me.

Why this question matters

A lot of writers frame habits as end-goals in themselves (“write 500 words a day,” “work out three times a week”). I’m more interested in the inflection point-the moment a fragile interest graduates into something that’s welded to identity. In other words:

When does a thing you do become a thing you are?

I’ve flirted with this question before, whether it was trying to journal after a long gap (Playing Catch-Up) or wondering if my “learn-all-the-things” binges could survive two solid weeks (Developing Interests vs Habits). But today I want to poke at the general pattern.

The 3-Lens Litmus Test

Lens What it asks How I check it
Autonomy Would I still do this if nobody asked me to? I spin up a side project instead of YouTube, just because tinkering feels good.
Resilience Does the habit bounce back after an unavoidable break? Miss a week of lifting while traveling? - Start the very next scheduled session, no make-ups.
Priority Will I defend it against higher-status temptations? Laptop snaps shut at 7 p.m. so I can start the stroller‑loop bedtime wind‑down, even if CI is red.

If a practice clears all three lenses, I’m comfortable calling it identity.

What flips the switch from interest → identity?

  1. Critical mass of reps My working number is 14 days plus one major obstacle. Miss a workout because the baby woke early? Bounce back the next day and the habit gains scar tissue. (This echoes the two-week threshold I floated in the Interests vs Habits post.)

  2. Decision friction drops to ~zero
    • Capsule wardrobe means gym shorts are always on top of the stack.
    • Git pre-commit hooks run linting so I don’t think about style rules.
    • Stroller waits by the door—blanket at the ready—so the 7 p.m. wind‑down walk makes bedtime less chaotic.
  3. Social reflection The identity solidifies quickest when someone else mirrors it back: “I can’t believe you’re going to the gym while on a cruise.” It’s silly, but that external label feels like epoxy.

“Identity isn’t claimed; it’s compounded.”

Mini-experiment: First Major Obstacle to the Upper-Lower Split

Back in February I launched my Upper-Lower Split for Busy Parents-four 45-minute sessions that fit between stand-ups and bedtime stories. For two straight months the calendar looked spotless. Then came the first real stress-test: a family flight from San Diego to Seattle.

Timeline What happened Why the routine survived
Trip Day 1 Travel day-no workout planned. Built-in margin; no guilt.
Trip Day 2 Located a gym near my parents’ place, squeezed in the scheduled Upper session (chest press + machine row, that’s it). Minimum viable session keeps the routine emotionally “alive.”
Trip Day 3 → 7 Woke up sick; stayed low-grade congested all week. I skipped the remaining sessions, took walks, and focused on sleep. Listen to your body: recovery outranks numbers.
Home Day 10 Fully recovered; picked up exactly where the split left off-“Lower” day with lighter loads to re-groove form. Resume, don’t restart. One comeback workout re-anchors the habit.

How the Seattle trip measured up to the lenses

  • Autonomy ✔︎ No one told me to hunt down a gym on Day 2-I wanted the training dose.
  • Resilience ✔︎ After a week of low-grade sickness I resumed, not restarted, right where the split left off.
  • Priority ✔︎ Recovery > ego lifts; family time > “catch-up” sets-so the habit served life, not the other way around.

That single comeback workout showed the routine can bend without breaking-exactly what the litmus test is looking for.

Key Lessons

  1. Plan for the pause. I allow myself to miss up to two consecutive sessions for illness or travel- no make-ups, no doubling.
  2. Do the smallest version that still feels like the program. A half-sized Upper day on unfamiliar machines was enough to keep the mental thread intact.
  3. Bounce back when the body says “go,” not the calendar. Missing a week didn’t erase two months of momentum; quitting would have.

That single “I’m back” workout mattered more than the perfect weeks before it. The habit is sturdier now, not because it was flawless, but because it proved it can bend and not break.

Any plan—upper‑lower, full‑body, or whatever mash-up you’re running—earns its stripes the first time life body‑checks you and the whole thing still lurches back to speed. Don’t chase perfection; chase the comeback rep. If your program bends without snapping, you can ride it for years, layering strength over software sprints until the routine feels less like something you do and more like the scaffolding of who you are.

Next Reads

If this resonated, queue up these next: